Woman Settles her Claim for the Misdiagnosis of Skin Cancer

A woman who was told she had a malignant melanoma after being informed the growth was benign has settled her claim for the misdiagnosis of skin cancer.

In February 2013, Joyce Huck (72) from Sutton-in-Craven, North Yorkshire, underwent surgery at Bradford Royal Infirmary to have a growth on her skin removed. Two separate tests reported that the growth was non-cancerous but, when the growth started to develop again, Joyce expressed her concerns to her GP.

The GP referred Joyce for a biopsy and, on Christmas Eve 2014, she was called back into the hospital and told she had a malignant melanoma. Joyce underwent further surgery in early 2015 to have the growth removed again, and samples were taken from her lymph nodes to determine if the cancer had spread to her organs. Fortunately she was given the all clear.

After recovering from the second round of surgery, Joyce sought legal advice and made a claim for the misdiagnosis of skin cancer against the Bradford Teaching Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust – alleging that the stress and anxiety she had suffered between the correct diagnosis being made and receiving the all clear had been very painful for her and her family.

The NHS Trust admitted a breach in its duty of care, and a five-figure settlement of Joyce´s claim for the misdiagnosis of skin cancer was agreed. The NHS Trust also publicly apologised for the stress and anxiety Joyce and her family had suffered, saying it was “deeply sorry”. A spokesman added: “The care we provided fell below our usual high standards and we sincerely apologise to Mrs Huck for this”.

Speaking after her claim for the misdiagnosis of skin cancer had been resolved, Joyce told her local newspaper: “At the time [of being called back to the hospital] I was not told the previous biopsies had been misreported. It was only when I was referred to a plastic surgeon for the growth to be completely removed that I was told the earlier biopsies had also shown cancer. It was shocking to think I’d been living with cancer for so long and it had been left untreated.”