UK Medical Negligence News

Cerebral Palsy Girl Awarded 5 Million Pounds Compensation

A twelve-year-old girl, who sustained severe brain damage due to mistakes made during her delivery, has been awarded 5 million pounds in a personal injury settlement.

Sophie Clarke (12) from Pontyclun, Rhondda Cynon Taf, was born in 1998 at the Princess of Wales Hospital, Bridgend. However, a gross abnormality of Sophie´s heart rate was not recognised, despite it registering on monitoring equipment.

Had staff at the Princess of Wales Hospital noticed Sophie´s condition, they would have intervened and delivery her by Caesarean Section. However, they allowed the birth to continue naturally, causing Sophie to suffer from a lack of oxygen in the womb.

Sophie suffers from severe cerebral palsy as a result of the errors made at the hospital and now needs twenty-four hour care, is fed via a tube and is confined to a wheelchair.

Solicitors acting on behalf of the family sued the Abertawe Bro Morgannwg University Health Board for negligence, and in a hearing at Cardiff Crown Court the negotiated settlement of 5 million pounds was approved.

Read More

Prisoners win 10 Million Pounds in Compensation Actions

A report released by the Ministry of Justice has shown that more than 10 million pounds has been awarded in compensation payments to prison inmates over the past five years.

Although the large majority of claims are in respect of “processing” delays, leading to the late release of prisoners, four payments in excess of 50,000 pounds were made in the last financial year in personal injury compensation and more than 1.6 million pounds in medical negligence compensation.

A representative from the Ministry of Justice said “The vast majority of prisoners’ compensation claims are relatively trivial, do not merit financial redress, and are dismissed at an early stage. All claims are robustly defended, and would only be settled on the basis of strong legal advice, and in order to seek the best value for the taxpayer. Compensation would then be determined following judicial guidelines and a full analysis of the available evidence.”

Read More

Seven Figure Compensation Award Anticipated for Little Joe

A ten-year-old Wolverhampton boy, who was brain damaged at birth due to alleged hospital malpractice, has won his battle for compensation.

Joseph O’Reggio from Wolverhampton, West Midlands, was born in April 2001 at the New Cross Hospital in Wolverhampton. Prior to his delivery, Mr Justice Tugendhat heard at London´s High Court, Joe was starved of oxygen and suffered brain damage as a result.

The consequences of his birth injury left Joe with cerebral palsy, wheelchair bound and suffering from severe learning difficulties. The Court also heard how Joe is unable to speak or feed himself.

It was claimed in an action against the Royal Wolverhampton NHS Trust that medical staff should have realised at an earlier stage that Joe was in distress and brought forward his delivery.

Although the NHS Trust denied that Joe´s injuries were caused by medical negligence, they agreed on the day before the trial was due to commence to admit 80 per cent liability for the claim, which will now go for assessment of damages.

Mr Justice Tugendhat approved the agreement, expressing his sympathy and best wishes to Joe´s parents.

Read More

Cuts in UK Legal Aid to Threaten Clinical Malpractice Claims

Representatives of the “Sound Off For Justice” campaign have claimed that proposed cuts in the amount of financial assistance given to claimants in UK civil cases could have devastating consequences for the victims of medical malpractice.

Legal Aid has been available for citizens of the UK ever since the end of the Second World War, but the cost of providing this facility has now spiralled out of control according to the Secretary of State for Justice, Ken Clarke. The current level of Legal Aid in the UK costs the taxpayer more than 2 billion pounds each year, and Mr Clarke would like to see this figure reduced by 350 million pounds before 2015.

This would still mean that Britain spends more money on Legal Aid than any other country in the world however justice campaigners have highlighted the case of Andrew Green from Grimsby as the type of legal claim which would no longer receive financial assistance.

Andrew was born in 1997 with cerebral palsy due to medical staff’s delays in dealing with complications during his delivery. Because his family qualified for Legal Aid, they were able to pay for an in-depth investigation into the circumstances of his birth and eventually secure compensation which will cover the cost of Andrew´s care for the rest of his life.

Campaigners claim that cuts to the programme could leave many families financially unable to claim compensation where medical negligence has occurred. Lawyers supporting the “Sound Off For Justice” campaign also claim that victims in cases involving divorce, employment law and other forms of professional malpractice will also suffer.

Officials from the Ministry of Justice say that no final decision has been made on the future of the Legal Aid programme following a public consultation period which attracted more than 5,000 responses.

Read More

DePuy Compensation Claim for Blood Poisoning Injury

A claim for blood poisoning injury has been made against DePuy Orthopaedics by a woman who received her DePuy ASR hip replacement system as recently as November 2009.
The DePuy claims action, made by Delores Hatcher from Wheeling, West Virginia, follows the results of a blood test in April 2011 which indicated high levels of chromium-1 and meta-cobalt in her blood – known causes of cardiovascular injury and neurological conditions such as headaches, confusion and cognitive decline, and possibly carcinogens which could lead to the development of cancer.

Delores added her claim to the growing number of Depuy compensation claims following the hip recall of August 2010 after visiting her doctor complaining of pain around her left hip and difficulty in walking. Both Delores and her doctor were overwhelmed by the outcome of the blood tests as the hip replacement was fitted in November 2009 and had failed in a short period of time.

In her claim for blood poisoning compensation, Delores also accused Johnson & Johnson – the parent company of DePuy Orthopaedics – of hiding known defects with the faulty hip replacement systems and alleges that they aggressively marketed the faulty hip replacement systems by paying kickbacks to medical supplies purchasers and orthopaedic surgeons.

Read More

U.S. Merges DePuy Pinnacle Injury Compensation Claims

Despite not being included in the DePuy hip recall of August 2010, the number of DePuy Pinnacle injury compensation claims in the United States has grown so quickly that legislators have merged them into one class action suit – known as a “multi-district litigation” case (MDL).

Over three hundred DePuy Pinnacle injury compensation claims have been filed to date – an alarming figure considering that the DePuy Pinnacle hip replacement system was not introduced to the market until five years after the recalled DePuy ASR hip replacement systems in 2008 – with each claiming injuries similar to those experienced by patients affected by the DePuy hip recall.

One of the reasons for such a significant failure rate is that no clinical testing was performed on the DePuy Pinnacle hip replacement system prior to launch on the American market. A process known as 501(k) was used to introduce the faulty hip replacement system into the United States whereby DePuy were able to show that the Pinnacle hip replacement system was similar in design and function to an existing hip replacement product already being used in the United States – the subsequently recalled DePuy ASR Acetabular System!

The MDL for the DePuy Pinnacle injury compensation claims will be held at United States District Court, Northern District of Texas, Dallas Division under Judge Ed Linkeade at a date still to be determined.

UPDATE February 2010: The number of claimants who have joined the MDL for DePuy Pinnacle injury compensation claims has risen to over 900. Unfortunately, a similar “grandfathering” process was used to introduce the Pinnacle hip replacement system into the UK and current advice from the UK Medicines Regulator is for recipients of the faulty metal on metal hip replacement system to have annual blood tests to check for high levels of cobalt and chromium entering the blood stream.

Read More

1 Million Pounds Heart Surgery Hospital Medical Negligence Compensation

Two teenagers, who claimed to have suffered disability following heart surgery at the Bristol Royal Infirmary when they were children, have each had hospital negligence compensation awards of 500,000 pounds approved in the High Court.

The teenagers – Kristian Dixon (19) and Jessica Johnson (18) – were both babies when undergoing heart surgery in 1992 and 1993 respectively. Mr Dixon claimed that brain damage sustained when he was sixteen months caused cognitive and learning difficulties, while Ms Johnson has required permanent care ever since her heart surgery.

It was alleged at the High Court in London that both had sustained brain damage due to professional misconduct by Surgeon Mr James Wisheart and hospital manager Dr John Roylance – who were struck off following a study into the deaths of 29 babies at the hospital between 1988 and 1995 – and Dr Janardan Dhasmana, who was barred from performing heart surgery at a disciplinary hearing in 1999.

Approving the awards, which were agreed by United Bristol Healthcare NHS Trust without admission of liability, Mr Justice Owen commended the families of both teenagers for the dedicated care they had given over the years.

Read More

40,000 Pounds Compensation for Fatal Emergency Misdiagnosis

The family of a Northumberland woman, who died after being misdiagnosed by an ambulance paramedic, has been awarded 40,000 pounds in medical negligence compensation.

Denise Hopper (40) from Alnmouth, Northumberland, was taken to hospital after being involved in a car crash in December 2007, in which she broke several vertebrae and suffered fractured ribs. The paramedic who treated her at the scene also diagnosed that she was suffering from dehydration, when in fact she had deep vein thrombosis. Denise consequently received the wrong treatment on her arrival at the hospital, and two weeks later suffered a heart attack and died.

Following an enquiry into her death, Denise’s two children sought legal advice and filed an action against the North East Ambulance Service for failing to demonstrate adequate clinical skills. The North East Ambulance Service admitted there had been a failure to make an accurate diagnosis, but did not admit liability for Denise’s death. Nonetheless, a compensation payment of 40,000 pounds for Denise’s children was agreed between legal representatives of the two sides.

Read More

Nursing Home Neglect Claim Settled for Undisclosed Amount

The family of a woman who died after sustaining horrific bed sores in Sheffield nursing home are to receive an undisclosed amount of compensation from the home for clinical neglect.

Doreen Betts (78) from Sheffield, South Yorkshire, died in May 2009 due to blood poisoning, after sores on her feet were left untreated for three months. The pathologist, who carried out the post-mortem on Mrs Betts, claimed at the inquest into her death that the sores were the worst grade they could have been, and penetrated so deeply that they reached the bone.

The family of Mrs Betts had claimed in their actions against Kersal Mount Nursing Home (now known as The Laurels and The Limes) that staff had been advised by Mrs Betts’ GP to seek expert advice on the sores, but none was ever arranged. It was only when Mrs Betts’ daughter had visited her mother that an ambulance was called and Mrs Betts taken to hospital.

Even though the condition of the sores improved under hospital care, Mrs Betts was also suffering from extreme dehydration and renal failure. The cause of death was determined as sepsis – an infection of the blood caused by pressure sores – and it was the opinion of the pathologist at the inquest that Mrs Betts would still be alive today had staff acted on the advice of her GP.

An undisclosed out-of-court compensation settlement was agreed between legal representatives of Mrs Betts’ family and the nursing home.

Read More

Multi-Million Celebral Palsy Compensation Due To 15 Minute Delay

An eight year old boy, who sustained terrible brain damage due to being starved of oxygen at his birth, has been awarded a multi-million pound compensation package by the High Court in London.

Callum Davies, of Abergavenny, Monmouthshire, was born at the Nevill Hall Hospital, Abergavenny in November 2002. A fifteen minute delay in his delivery starved his brain of oxygen, and resulted in Callum sustaining dyskinetic cerebral palsy and brain damage.

Claiming medical negligence against the Gwent Healthcare NHS Trust through his father Paul, Callum will now need extensive care for the remainder of his life – care which has been provided for him to date by his parents.

The health board which succeeded Gwent Healthcare NHS Trust in 2009 – the Anuerin Bevan Health Board – admitted liability for Callum’s birth injury and issued an apology in front of Mrs Justice Nicola Davies at the High Court.

Announcing details of the compensation package, Judge Davies approved an immediate payment of 2.275 million pounds in order to adapt the family home and provide an education programme for Callum. Further annual payments will be made by the NHS Trust to cover the cost of his care.

Addressing Callum’s parents in court, the judge added “It is clear that the care which you and your wife have given is of the highest order. I know that Callum’s injuries have impacted on you and your whole family as a unit and that is something which at times is very, very difficult for families. I am well aware that the settlement approved by the court is not the complete answer, but what I do hope for the family is that these monies will make life easier”.

Read More